Mistletoe Movies

MISTLETOE MOVIES

The Definitive Holiday Films

From Santa Claus (1898) to the Present Day

by: Douglas Brode

Watching favorite holiday movies has always been a tradition in my family.
Starting about Thanksgiving, as the days grow shorter and Christmas approaches,
every looks forward to “Love, Actually,” “A Christmas Carol,” “Home Alone,” “A
Christmas Story,”... and “Die Hard.”

There are so many that are special, sentimental, funny, crazy and perfect that it’s painful
to have to truncate that list for the sake of space in this column.

So I was very excited to discover that Douglas Brode, a scholar and writer about all
things film, local celebrity, actor, novelist, and celebrity biographer had created the
ultimate compendium of Christmas movies, from the earliest modern Santa of The Night
Before Christmas, to the present day, in a to-be-published in time for Christmas giving
guide book to Christmas movies!

I eagerly jumped into the book, expecting to find a simple rendering of what I figured I
mostly knew, only to discover that I had a lot more to learn!

Of course, the title should give it away - he went all the way back to 1898 the George
Albert release of a silent film “Santa Claus,” the first, though certainly not the last,
appearance of the beloved character on film.

And from there, you’re off on a “sleigh ride” through the films of the 20s, 30s, 40s and
maybe more before you begin to see the names of movies you’ll recognize from your
childhood - but based on his insightful descriptions and thoughtful musings on the
meanings and deeper sociological import of each movie, you’re likely to want, as I do, to
watch every one of them this season.

I had lots of questions for the writer and film critic, and here, shared with you this
holiday, are his answers.

Q: What inspired you to write this book? I know film is your first love, but was there
something special about Christmas?

I have always adored the holiday season, ever since I was a small kid. Though I am
Jewish, my family did live in a highly integrated middle class neighborhood. Everybody
celebrated and we were always a part of that. Of course, Hanukah – which is included
in my book – was a part of it. A major part. But there was Thanksgiving first and New
Year’s Eve at the end. And now of course Kwanzaa added to the mix. And as my family
was not a particularly religious one, I was free to adore the secular side of it all. I think of
all holiday movies, the one that most captures my own memories is A CHRISTMAS
STORY. How important is it that the film never includes any mention of the religious
aspects. The family never goes to church, though such a family likely would in real life.
And yet they experience something that is very spiritual – which runs across any and all
specific religions. A spirit of good will to men. Santa Claus parade, followed by a visit to
the big store in town. I believe the reason that A CHRISTMAS STORY is so incredibly
popular has as much to do with that sense of coming together at year’s end -
expressing the best sides of our selves after failing to do so many times during the past
year - as it does with the film’s incredible comedy bits. Everyone, of any religion, can
relate to what we see onscreen. As my friend, the film director Rod Lurie exclaimed
when I told him about this project: “Well, we Jews have written some of the best ever
Christmas songs. (THINK: Irving Berlin!) Why shouldn’t one of us write the book about
Christmas movies as well?” I do believe that I love the holiday season in the same
manner that Irving Berlin did. It’s become an AMERICAN ritual. For all to partake of from
the end of November to early January. When, sad to say, the world all too often turns
grey again.
 
Q: What’s your short list of Christmas movies?

At the top of my list would be WHITE CHRISTMAS (1954). I was eleven when I first saw
it. The film begins during the Battle of the Bulge, which my own father was a part of in
real life. The soldiers gathered in Bastogne sing Irving Berlin’s song in a melancholy
way. They all wish they were home to begin ‘the best years of our lives.’ The dream that
everything would be rosy once the war was over. But that didn’t happen. The Cold War
with Russia, the hot conflict in Korea, a postwar recession . . . everything in society
turned dark. And in the movies as well: Film Noir emerged. Then, the film jumps to
‘today’ – 1954 – and everyone is a part of the lonely crowd. They miss ‘the good old
days’ of 1944, when a common cause – our Crusade in Europe – drew everyone
together, whether at home or overseas. There’s even a song called “Gee! I wish I was
back in the army.” The film is about trying to recapture something that had been lost
during the past decade. I think this may have been the first time I ever realized, on
some level at least, that there is a strong connection between the movies we watch and
the daily lives we are living. Movies aren’t merely an escape from real life. They can be
a means of helping us to comprehend the bigger picture. Which we then share as time
goes by. Additionally, I love all the other most famous ones: IT’S A WONDERFUL LIFE,
MIRACLE ON 34th STREET . . . I enjoy watching one each evening throughout
December. Also, what I think is the greatest ever version of Charles Dickens’ A
CHRISTMAS CAROL: the 1951 film with Alastair Sim. He brilliantly does away with the
incorrect notion that Scrooge is a mean, nasty, caricatured villain. And replaces that
mistaken cliché with what Dickens intended. Here is a tragic hero in the Shakesperean
sense - a once good, even great man who was beaten down by life’s disappointments.
And the manner in which he finds redemption. Watching Sim as Scrooge is like
watching Laurence Olivier in the 1948 version of Hamlet. Once you’ve seen it, none of
the others quite measure up.

Q: You said “Fanny and Alexander” - which I have never seen - is the BEST Christmas
movie. What’s your FAVORITE, LEAST FAVORITE, and the worst (least “Christmas”)?
Well, there are ‘good bad movies’ and ‘bad bad movies.’ I most despise SANTA CLAUS
= THE MOVIE, which is a big expensive empty flop from the 1980s. Dudley Moore
(anybody still remember him?) Is one of Santa’s elves. It was so carefully planned to be
a big box office hit and then it bombed, with audiences and critics. Money can’t buy
happiness, as the saying goes. Or quality. It’s cold, unemotional, unappealing. And do
you notice that it never shows up on TV today? The public sensed its artificiality and
does not wish to see it again. On the other hand, there’s SANTA CLAUS CONQUERS
THE MARTIANS. True, it’s awful, in a sense. Very cheap, goofy . . . and yet it’s fun. A
holiday themed ‘guilty pleasure.’ And there truly is a sense in it of what I consider to be
the most important Mistletoe Movie theme of all: Family. A family that has grown apart,
and comes together again at this special time of year. HOME ALONE is about that. And
so is DIE HARD. That theme cuts across everything from silly comedies to action flicks
that are truly about the magic of the holiday season.
 
Q: I’ve often thought that movies make, or at least influence, culture - and that was
probably true of theater, poetry, music. But movies always seemed to me to have
significant power over styles and interests and tastes. Did Hollywood help define our
ideas of what is “Christmas?”

As the British romantic poet William Wordworth said: “We learn by imitation.” In the
modern world, we imitate – whether we are aware of it not – what see in movies and on
TV. One of my great fascinations with entertainment is the manner in which it both
reflects the changing lifestyle that’s out there but also influences further change. The
Bing Crosby Christmas musicals, in which he plays a parish priest, are warmhearted
and delightful. But they also reflect the reduction of much prejudice against the Irish as
an ethnic group that belatedly took place in the postwar years. But watching those films
also helped to increase that acceptance. Anglos fell in love with Crosby and Barry
Fitzgerald while watching. And, most important, took that warmth, that new acceptance
and respect, home with them. Not that a movie can make all the bad stuff go away
overnight. But movies can certainly help to create a more tolerant society. Same holds
true for the animated AN AMERICAN TAIL regarding Jewish people. The mass
audience went to see it in its time. And loved little ‘Fievel’ and his cap, his Hanukah
present for the season. In a small way, perhaps, but in a good way, people leave the
theatre in a more mellow sense than when they went in. Particularly with such holiday
films. More recently, THE BLACK CANDLE beautifully explains Kwanza to all of us.
 
Q: As I note in the introduction, I have been building a list of must-watch Christmas
movies, and I noticed a few of my favorites didn’t make your cut. Give me a reaction to
them:
Love, Actually
Jingle All The Way
About a Boy
A Castle For Christmas
The Christmas Candle

Well there’s only so much space in any book, and I did narrow the number of main
entries down to 100. But many that did not make the list are included in the
supplements at the back of the book. Runners-up that people may have never heard of.
I think a little New York City film called 29 th Street is fabulous – kind of It’s a Wonderful
Life reset in Manhattan’s mean streets. I hope my book will call attention to that. There’s
also a large section at the end where I list and analyze all the greatest TV animated
specials: Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer, Santa Claus is Coming to Town, A Charlie
Brown Christmas. Also important: In my top 100, I include a number of films that most
people would not necessarily think of as holiday films. The 1940s supernatural thriller
CAT PEOPLE. The 1950s Serial Killer tale THE NIGHT OF THE HUNTER. For me,
these are essential viewing. Each takes an innocent child on a journey through the dark
side that is thankfully resolved on Christmas morning. Each is about good ultimately
conquering evil. To me, that’s a Mistletoe Movie in a nutshell!


Comments

Popular Posts